Meta Description: Join Dr. David Noe and Dr. Jeff Winkle on the Ad Navseam Podcast as they explore Book 2 of Cicero’s De Natura Deorum. Discover the Stoic arguments for a rational universe, the meaning of pronoea, and why a sundial proves the existence of the gods.
Introduction: The Stoic Turn
Welcome back to the “vomitorium,” listeners! In Episode 72 of the Ad Navseam Podcast, hosts Dr. David Noe and Dr. Jeff Winkle return to “Vomitorium West” to continue their deep dive into one of the most important philosophical works of the Latin language: Cicero’s De Natura Deorum (On the Nature of the Gods).
In the previous episode, we saw the Epicurean view—that the gods exist but are essentially on a permanent vacation, indifferent to human affairs—get dismantled. Now, in Book 2, the conversation takes a serious turn. We move from the atomistic randomness of Epicurus to the ordered, purposeful universe of the Stoics.
The primary speaker is Lucilius Balbus, whom Cicero describes as not just a Stoic, but the Stoic. His arguments for the existence of a divine mind are sophisticated and foundational for understanding Roman theology.
The Argument from Common Consent
Balbus begins his defense not with complex logic, but with a simple observation: look up at the sky.
- ** Ennius’s Line:** Balbus quotes the father of Roman poetry, Ennius: “Look upon this dazzling sky, which all men invoke as Jove.”
- The Consensus: Balbus argues that the existence of the gods is so obvious that it requires no proof. It is engraved in the minds of all people (insculptum). If it weren’t true, the belief would have faded away like a bad rumor. Instead, belief in the divine has only grown stronger over time.
Dr. Noe notes that this is the Argument from Common Consent (Consensus Gentium). If everyone, everywhere, for all time has believed in something, isn’t it likely to be true? Or at least, isn’t the burden of proof on the atheist to explain why everyone else is wrong?
The Universe is God (Mundus est Deus)
Here is where the Stoics get radical. They don’t just believe that a god created the universe; they believe the universe is God.
- ** Zeno’s Syllogism:** Dr. Winkle breaks down a famous syllogism from Zeno of Citium (the founder of Stoicism):
- That which has reason is better than that which does not.
- Nothing is better than the Universe (Mundus).
- Therefore, the Universe has reason.
The Stoics view the cosmos as a living, breathing, thinking organism. Just as you are a soul inhabiting a body, God is the soul inhabiting the universe. This is Pantheism. The universe isn’t a dead machine; it is a divine being.
The Heat of Life
Balbus argues that “heat” (calor) is the essential element of life. Since the universe is full of heat (the sun, the stars, the internal heat of the earth), it must be alive. Dr. Noe points out that while the physics might be outdated, the intuition—that energy is the basis of existence—is profound.
The Argument from Design
Perhaps the most famous part of Book 2 is Cicero’s use of analogies to prove that the world is the result of conscious design rather than random chance.
The Sundial and the Water Clock
Cicero uses the example of a sundial or a water clock (clepsydra).
- The Argument: If you see a sundial or a water clock, you know it tells time by art (ars) and not by chance (casus).
- The Application: How then can you look at the cosmos—which possesses a complex order that allows the sundial to work in the first place—and conclude it is devoid of purpose and reason?
The “Posidonius Sphere”
Cicero mentions a device made by his friend Posidonius: a mechanical sphere that replicated the movements of the sun, moon, and five planets.
- The Thought Experiment: If you took this sphere to Scythia or Britain (places considered “barbarous” by Romans), even the locals would instantly recognize it as the product of a rational mind.
- The Conclusion: If a model of the universe requires a creator, surely the universe itself—which is infinitely more complex and perfect—requires a creator.
This is a direct attack on the Epicurean idea that the universe formed by the random collision of atoms. As Balbus scoffs, that is as likely as throwing the twenty-one letters of the alphabet onto the ground and having them accidentally spell out the Annals of Ennius.
** Pronoea: The Teaching of Providence**
The Stoics introduce a key Greek term into the Latin philosophical lexicon: Pronoea.
- Translation: Cicero translates this Greek word as Providentia (Providence/Foresight).
- Meaning: It is not a specific goddess, but the active, rational power that governs the universe.
Balbus argues that the universe is governed by a “Sentient Nature” (Natura Sentientem) that manages the world with perfect skill. He calls this nature sollers (skillful/artistic).
- ** Natura non Artificiosa:** Nature is not just “artistic” in a metaphorical sense; it is a literal craftsman (artifex). It shapes the world like a potter shapes clay, but from the inside out.
Dr. Noe highlights the beauty of this concept. Nature isn’t a blind force; it is an intelligent fire that guides the growth of every plant and the movement of every star.
The Anthropocentric Cosmos
Finally, Balbus argues that this divine order is not just for show—it is for us.
- The City of Gods and Men: The universe is a “common home” (domus communis) shared by gods and humans.
- Uniquely Human: Only humans can appreciate the beauty of the stars, the order of the seasons, and the bounty of the earth. Therefore, the world was made for the sake of gods and men.
This is a high view of humanity. We are not just accidents of biology; we are the “spectators of the sky” (caeli spectatores), created to stand upright and contemplate the divine.
Conclusion: Food as Impermanent Art
As the hosts wrap up this tour of Stoic theology, they turn to a lighter subject for the Gustatory Parting Shot.
This week’s wisdom comes from Julie Piatt (author of The Plant Power Way). While the hosts are skeptical of the “plant-based” premise (fearing a lack of “bakos”), they appreciate her insight on the nature of cooking:
“Unlike a painting or a sculpture, food is an impermanent, fleeting art form. It’s a momentary artistic offering, the enjoyment of which necessitates its destruction.”
Just as the Stoics believed the universe goes through cycles of creation and destruction (conflagration), your sandwich is made only to be unmade.
Valete!
Sponsors:
- Hackett Publishing: Use the coupon code AN2022 for 20% off and free shipping on your next order of classical texts.
- Ratio Coffee: For a coffee machine that is built like a tank but brews like an artist, use the code ANCO for 15% off.
- Gold River Trading Co: Tea drinkers, rejoice! Use the code ANTEA for 15% off premium American teas.
The Moss Method: Learn Greek from scratch or master Latin composition with Dr. Noe.
